Eye of Sauron Cake

Favorite
Eye of Sauron Cake
- -

Hey since you're all-seeing, can you let me know if you notice any ulcers in there?

LOTR Cake

Favorite
LOTR Cake
- -

Eat your way through Middle Earth, but skip the Entsongs layer, they're all musty and boring tasting.

One Candy to Rule Them All

Favorite
One Candy to Rule Them All
- -

It makes perfect sense that if you tipped Gandalf's head back and lifted up his beard, there'd be candy in there. It took them long enough!